Because Peter is the authority, Bridget and I decided that we should make Peter's vote count more. "What about two?" I asked. "That's good", she compromised.

Peter said "I think I like the one with the dots" as he pointed at his own eyes, disappointing me deeply.

But my heart stabbed by disappointment soon got healed as I realized my hypothesis that old people like :) was quite convincing and interesting. So I smiled stupidly.